• Latest
  • Trending
  • All
  • Finance
  • Politics
  • US News
  • Political Humor
  • Tech
American Health Care Is Understaffed, Because It Is Overregulated

American Health Care Is Understaffed, Because It Is Overregulated

May 20, 2022
Op-ed: Biden Must Leverage The African Diaspora

Op-Ed: Uncovering the Untapped Potential of African Intelligence Services

February 2, 2023

How To Choose The Best Saree Blouse Designs For Each Occasion?

January 31, 2023
Achieving Greater Efficiency with Accounts Payable Automation

Achieving Greater Efficiency with Accounts Payable Automation

January 27, 2023
digital signage for business

How Can Digital Signage Analytics Help You Make Better Business Decisions?

January 25, 2023

SIX Reasons to Buy Tequila Online

January 18, 2023

Tips and Tricks to Choose the Best House Cleaning Services

January 17, 2023
Girl with Shopping bag

8 Super Effective Shopping Tips to Save More Money in Chandigarh Malls 2023

January 4, 2023
Cabana brings integrated camper van travel experiences to markets nationwide

Cabana brings integrated camper van travel experiences to markets nationwide

December 13, 2022
Right Background for Photography

21 Tips to Choose Right Background for Photography

December 5, 2022

Op-ed: What leaders can do to ensure that peace and security is achieved and sustained in Africa?

December 4, 2022
LIVE World Cup Watch Party 10AM/ET US Vs Netherlands – Here Saturday 10AM/ET

LIVE World Cup Watch Party 10AM/ET US Vs Netherlands – Here Saturday 10AM/ET

December 2, 2022
Bangladesh: Building Smart Communities to Hasten Vision 2041

Bangladesh: Building Smart Communities to Hasten Vision 2041

December 2, 2022
  • About
Friday, February 3, 2023
  • Login
  • Register
Inside The Nation
  • Daily Buzz
    Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

    Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

    What You Need To Know About Appointees To U.S. Holocaust Memorial Council

    Biden’s Speech At Democracy Summit Calls For Action

    Op-ed: Give Joe Biden a Break

    Analysis: What Is Ahead For U.S. Markets In 2022?

    White House Releases Statement On The Occasion Of Orthodox Christmas

    Antonio Brown explains his Sunday football outburst

  • US News
    • All
    • EDUCATION
    An employee of Toyota in West Virginia. Photo via Toyota

    Toyota Invests in Appalachia EV Production

    Trump’s Other Muslim Ban

    What’s A College Degree Worth Anyway?

    MLB player banned from visiting family

    Biden’s Speech At Democracy Summit Calls For Action

    Op-ed: Biden’s Way Foward

    Antonio Brown explains his Sunday football outburst

  • Politics
    • All
    • international News
    Op-ed: Biden Must Leverage The African Diaspora

    Op-Ed: Uncovering the Untapped Potential of African Intelligence Services

    Op-ed: What leaders can do to ensure that peace and security is achieved and sustained in Africa?

    Bangladesh: Building Smart Communities to Hasten Vision 2041

    Bangladesh: Building Smart Communities to Hasten Vision 2041

    The 4Rs of Tanzania President Samia

    Op-ed: Biden Must Leverage The African Diaspora

    African Intelligence Services Must Reform To Fight Terrorism

    Africa in the Face of Global Food Crises

    The Catalysts Of Africa’s Sustainable Development Trajectory

    Houthi Leader Proclaims Support For Russia in Anti-Semitic Comment

    Houthi Leader Proclaims Support For Russia in Anti-Semitic Comment

    Photo-Essay: The Faces of Lake Buhi In The Philippines

    Photo-Essay: The Faces of Lake Buhi In The Philippines

    Op-ed: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and The End of Peace,

    Op-ed: Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and The End of Peace,

    • Political Humor

      SIX Reasons to Buy Tequila Online

      Tips and Tricks to Choose the Best House Cleaning Services

      Forced Uyghur Labor Still Found in Fashion Industry

      Forced Uyghur Labor Still Found in Fashion Industry

      UAE First Arab Country To Provide Aid Ukraine As Conflict Rages

      UAE First Arab Country To Provide Aid Ukraine As Conflict Rages

      Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

      Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

      Foreign and Commonwealth Office - Freedom of religion or belief

      “Mulilateralism Lies On Its Deathbed” Says Kenya Diplomat in Powerful Ukraine speech

      DON’T EXPECT THE FED TO END THIS BULL ANYTIME SOON

      Pugilist Kieth Thurman Speaks On The Importance of Black History Month

      Pugilist Kieth Thurman Speaks On The Importance of Black History Month

      Analysis: What Is Ahead For U.S. Markets In 2022?

  • Business
    • All
    • Finance
    • Marketing
    • Tech

    How To Choose The Best Saree Blouse Designs For Each Occasion?

    Achieving Greater Efficiency with Accounts Payable Automation

    Achieving Greater Efficiency with Accounts Payable Automation

    digital signage for business

    How Can Digital Signage Analytics Help You Make Better Business Decisions?

    Girl with Shopping bag

    8 Super Effective Shopping Tips to Save More Money in Chandigarh Malls 2023

    Cabana brings integrated camper van travel experiences to markets nationwide

    Cabana brings integrated camper van travel experiences to markets nationwide

    Right Background for Photography

    21 Tips to Choose Right Background for Photography

    Bangladesh: Building Smart Communities to Hasten Vision 2041

    Bangladesh: Building Smart Communities to Hasten Vision 2041

    Improve Traffic With SEO

    How to Improve Traffic With SEO

    Best Offline Games For Android To Play Without Connection

    Best Offline Games For Android To Play Without Connection

  • Entertainment
    LIVE World Cup Watch Party 10AM/ET US Vs Netherlands – Here Saturday 10AM/ET

    LIVE World Cup Watch Party 10AM/ET US Vs Netherlands – Here Saturday 10AM/ET

    2PM/ET Tuesday LIVE Inside the Nation – USA Vs. Iran World Cup Watch Party

    2PM/ET Tuesday LIVE Inside the Nation – USA Vs. Iran World Cup Watch Party

    Review: Independent Film “Paul’s Promise” Surprises Critics, Linking Anti-Racism To Faith

    Review: Independent Film “Paul’s Promise” Surprises Critics, Linking Anti-Racism To Faith

    Antonio Brown explains his Sunday football outburst

    Travel: Hidden Gems Near Tokyo For Day-Trippers

    Photo by Erik Drost of Enes Kanter via Wikipedia

    Shaquille O’Neal Criticizes Enes Kanter Freedom

    Photo by Erik Drost of Enes Kanter via Wikipedia

    NBA Star Enes Kanter Adds “Freedom” To His Name

    In a punk ‘Cruella,’ dogs play second fiddle to the designs

    In a punk ‘Cruella,’ dogs play second fiddle to the designs

    HBO Max welcomes back the cast of “Friends,” for a reunion

    HBO Max welcomes back the cast of “Friends,” for a reunion

    Florida takes the step to get into the Sports Gaming Business

    Florida takes the step to get into the Sports Gaming Business

  • Environment

    SIX Reasons to Buy Tequila Online

    Tips and Tricks to Choose the Best House Cleaning Services

    Forced Uyghur Labor Still Found in Fashion Industry

    Forced Uyghur Labor Still Found in Fashion Industry

    UAE First Arab Country To Provide Aid Ukraine As Conflict Rages

    UAE First Arab Country To Provide Aid Ukraine As Conflict Rages

    Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

    Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

    Foreign and Commonwealth Office - Freedom of religion or belief

    “Mulilateralism Lies On Its Deathbed” Says Kenya Diplomat in Powerful Ukraine speech

    DON’T EXPECT THE FED TO END THIS BULL ANYTIME SOON

    Pugilist Kieth Thurman Speaks On The Importance of Black History Month

    Pugilist Kieth Thurman Speaks On The Importance of Black History Month

    Analysis: What Is Ahead For U.S. Markets In 2022?

  • Health

    SIX Reasons to Buy Tequila Online

    Tips and Tricks to Choose the Best House Cleaning Services

    Forced Uyghur Labor Still Found in Fashion Industry

    Forced Uyghur Labor Still Found in Fashion Industry

    UAE First Arab Country To Provide Aid Ukraine As Conflict Rages

    UAE First Arab Country To Provide Aid Ukraine As Conflict Rages

    Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

    Hershey’s Creates Chocolate Bar to Celebrate All Women and Girls

    Foreign and Commonwealth Office - Freedom of religion or belief

    “Mulilateralism Lies On Its Deathbed” Says Kenya Diplomat in Powerful Ukraine speech

    DON’T EXPECT THE FED TO END THIS BULL ANYTIME SOON

    Pugilist Kieth Thurman Speaks On The Importance of Black History Month

    Pugilist Kieth Thurman Speaks On The Importance of Black History Month

    Analysis: What Is Ahead For U.S. Markets In 2022?

No Result
View All Result
Inside The Nation
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

American Health Care Is Understaffed, Because It Is Overregulated

The pandemic highlighted the need for more doctors and nurses.

by Nick Ottens
May 20, 2022
in Business, Health
0
American Health Care Is Understaffed, Because It Is Overregulated

Ambulance in Manhattan, New York, October 4, 2017 (Unsplash/Benjamin Voros)

502
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

American Health Care Is Understaffed, Because It Is Overregulated

The pandemic highlighted the need for more doctors and nurses.

Ambulance in Manhattan, New York, October 4, 2017 (Unsplash/Benjamin Voros)

If coronavirus convinces more people our health-care systems need to be overhauled, it may be one of the few good outcomes of the pandemic.

In the UK, the government-owned National Health Service has long underperformed relative to its rich-country peers. I wrote here in January that the pandemic has underscored the need for reform. If you subscribe to the Financial Times, also read Camilla Cavendish’s story from April about the hundreds of babies who died in English maternity wards between 2000 and 2019 from lack of care. This in the world’s fifth-largest economy!

The Netherlands’ mixed public-private system is superior, but the country still has a shortage of nurses. It’s something I investigated for Wynia’s Week in December. What I found was that nursing associations, trade unions and researchers have been sounding the alarm for years, yet hospitals continue to underpay nurses and few give their workers the autonomy and flexibility they ask for. Probably because nursing was historically a part-time profession of unmarried women, and doctors and hospital administrators were historically older and male. That hierarchical culture (which I imagine exists in other countries as well) is hard to change, but it is slowly starting to. If you read Dutch, you can glean examples from my second story on the topic.

In America, excessive licensing requirements and regulations have kept health care understaffed. Pro-market think tanks like the Cato Institute and Niskanen Center have been trying to draw attention to this. Even Vox, hardly a bastion of libertarianism, acknowledges that American health care is, in some ways, overregulated.

Overregulated

In normal times, a shortage of medical personnel would just lead to higher prices. In a crisis, it can cause people to go without treatment and die.

Vox reports there are two reasons America doesn’t have enough health-care professionals:

  1. You can’t practice medicine with an out-of-state license. States don’t recognize each others’ certificates nor foreign diplomas.
  2. Nurses are seldom allowed to carry out medical procedures without the supervision of a doctor.

Dylan Scott, the author, knows there can be good reasons for such restrictions. Not every medical degree is equivalent. Not every nurse can do everything. Insurance companies often require a doctor to sign off before they reimburse the treatment.

But the regulations also protect the turf and livelihood of doctors. Making it difficult for out-of-state physicians to practice, and requiring the involvement of a doctor in even routine procedures nurses may have performed a hundred times before, allows doctors to make more money.

Nobody is proposing to abolish all rules and let anyone practice anything, but some rules could be relaxed.

The good news is that almost half the states in America have. Since the start of the pandemic, 24 have eased licensing requirements for physicians, 21 have expedited the licensing of retired or inactive doctors, and twenty have temporarily liberalized scope-of-practice regulations for nurse practitioners.

Allocating workers

Not every state needs more health workers. Connecticut, New Jersey and New York have plenty of doctors. States in the Rocky Mountain West have the highest shortages, in particular Arizona, North Dakota and Wyoming.

Scott is sympathetic to a form of central planning to optimize the allocation of doctors and nurses. (It’s still Vox.) That might be justifiable in an emergency, but I would be wary of attempting to move people around. Nobody could be forced to relocate (it’s still America), but as soon as you give an authority the power to “allocate” resources that opens the door to people being pressured to leave or institutions with a surplus of workers losing funding.

It may be unnecessary anyway if states recognized each others’ medical licenses. A doctor from California who is close to retirement may want to practice a few more years part-time in rural Wyoming. A nurse who moved out of state to get a degree may want to move back to his hometown. Regulations don’t make it easy for either of them. If doctors and nurses could move from state to state without having to worry so much about paperwork, probably more would. Then the market, not a planning agency, would improve what economists call the allocation of labor resources.

Evening out wages

Mutual recognition of licenses should also help even out wages. As is the case in the Netherlands, in many parts of the United States nurses are underpaid, even though there is a national shortage. A freer labor market would be a more national labor market. Nurses working in an expensive state like California would still need to earn more, but perhaps not twice as much as nurses in North Dakota and West Virginia.

If some places remain underserved, rather than a national planning board I would introduce a health-care version of the Teacher Loan Forgiveness Program. The federal government pays the student debts of graduates who teach in low-income schools for five years. If America is willing to subsidize the education of teachers, why not doctors and nurses?

Scott understands that high debts incentivize students to pursue specializations that are lucrative, which causes others to be understaffed. The prospect of the entirety of your debt being forgiven in five years should motivate more students to specialize in what they’re interested in, not in what they think will make them the most money.

Congress created the shortage

One thing Scott doesn’t mention is that lawmakers created the shortage of doctors.

Robert Orr of the Niskanen Center points out that America had more physicians per capita than other Western democracies in the 1960s. That convinced policymakers in the 1970s the number ought to be reduced, which led Congress to curtail medical residency slots in 1980.

Residencies are generally funded through Medicare, which generates direct costs to the federal government, and Congress didn’t want to spend the money. America now has relatively fewer doctors than Canada and Europe.

This has been good for doctors, who have seen their salaries rise at twice the rate of inflation. It’s been hard on American consumers, who pay twice as much of their income on health care as they did in the 1980s, and twice as much as European and other wealthy nations do today.

Comments
Nick Ottens
+ posts
  • Nick Ottens
    #molongui-disabled-link
    Explained: America’s $1 Trillion Infrastructure Bill
  • Nick Ottens
    #molongui-disabled-link
    Op-Ed: Is Biden Facing his "De Gaulle" Moment?
  • Nick Ottens
    #molongui-disabled-link
    Op-ed: Give Joe Biden a Break
  • Nick Ottens
    #molongui-disabled-link
    Op-ed: Biden's Way Foward
Share201Tweet126Share35SharePin45
Nick Ottens

Nick Ottens

    Subscribe To Our Newsletter

    Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from the ITN Network.




    We respect your privacy. Please read our Privacy Policy. You can opt-out of emails at anytime.

    Plugin Install : Widget Tab Post needs JNews - View Counter to be installed
    • Trending
    • Comments
    • Latest
    Hitman shoots husband and kills son of Judge overseeing Deutsche Bank Epstein trial

    Hitman shoots husband and kills son of Judge overseeing Deutsche Bank Epstein trial

    July 20, 2020
    Tanzanian President Samia’s trip to Europe Is a Strategic Move

    Tanzanian President Samia’s trip to Europe Is a Strategic Move

    February 18, 2022
    The wealthiest people in the world today

    The wealthiest people in the world today

    July 4, 2020
    The Role of AI in Human Resources

    The Role of AI in Human Resources

    1
    Girl with Shopping bag

    8 Super Effective Shopping Tips to Save More Money in Chandigarh Malls 2023

    1
    Points of View: Right Wing versus Left Wing One Century of the Bolshevik Revolution

    Points of View: Right Wing versus Left Wing One Century of the Bolshevik Revolution

    0
    Op-ed: Biden Must Leverage The African Diaspora

    Op-Ed: Uncovering the Untapped Potential of African Intelligence Services

    February 2, 2023

    How To Choose The Best Saree Blouse Designs For Each Occasion?

    January 31, 2023
    Achieving Greater Efficiency with Accounts Payable Automation

    Achieving Greater Efficiency with Accounts Payable Automation

    January 27, 2023
    Inside The Nation

    Copyright © 2020 Inside The Nation.

    Navigate Site

    • About

    Follow Us

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Daily Buzz
    • US News
    • Politics
      • Political Humor
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Environment
    • Health

    Copyright © 2020 Inside The Nation.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Create New Account!

    OR

    Fill the forms below to register

    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In

    Sign up to best Trending News, Politics, Finance in United States.

    Get special offers that you won't ever find on our blog·

    Invalid email address
    We promise not to spam you. You can unsubscribe at any time
    Thanks for subscribing!